2011 · Album
The Windmills Of Your Mind
Recorded 2011 · Winter & Winter · Produced by Not publicly documented
Paul Motian's Final Statement on Winter & Winter
A drummer at ease with silence, space, and the particular voices around him.
Paul Motian recorded The Windmills of Your Mind (2011) near the end of his life, and it shows a musician still listening intently, still curious about what happens when you leave room for others to breathe. This is late-period Motian, which means the drums are less about timekeeping and more about conversation — he plays in the spaces between notes as much as on the beat itself. With Bill Frisell on guitar, Thomas Morgan on bass, and vocalist Petra Haden, Motian assembled musicians who understand that restraint can be its own kind of power.
Frisell has worked with Motian for decades by this point, and they move together with the ease of people who've played hundreds of times. What's striking here is how much air surrounds everything — this isn't a crowded session. Haden's voice becomes an instrument rather than a lyrical vehicle, and Morgan's bass anchors things without pushing. Motian's drums shimmer, tap, suggest. The title track and others have a chamber music quality that's rare in jazz. It's intimate without being precious.
This isn't an album for people who want rhythm sections to charge forward. If you come in expecting a drummer to drive the engine, you'll miss what's happening. But if you've heard Motian's work with the Paul Motian Trio or his collaborations with saxophonists over the years, you know he's always been more interested in architecture than propulsion. This record is quieter than some of his earlier work, more reflective. It's a good place to understand how a master musician thinks about the drums as something closer to a paintbrush than a hammer. Not every player can make that work. Motian could.
Who's playing
Where next?
More by Paul Motian
All 14 albums →
The musicians on this record
Their own records, close in time
