McRae singing these songs feels like overhearing someone who knows exactly what they're doing.
Something Wonderful arrives as Carmen McRae working through a collection of songs made famous by the women who sang them in Broadway musicals. This is a deliberate choice, not a standard jazz vocalist's album of standards. Buddy Bregman arranged and conducted the sessions, and Teo Macero produced—so the sound has shape and intention behind it.
McRae had already built a reputation as a skilled interpreter by 1963, and this album sits comfortably in that part of her work. She wasn't trying to reinvent these songs or deconstruct them. Instead, she sings them the way someone who has studied them would—with respect for the material, clear understanding of the lyrics, and enough confidence to make them hers without overreaching. Bregman's arrangements give her room to land on what matters in each song. The album works best when you sit with individual tracks rather than treating it as background music. This is closer to recital than jam session.
It's a solid album that reaches for something specific: showing these Broadway songs through a jazz singer's sensibility. It didn't become one of her defining records, and it's not the best starting point for someone new to McRae. But if you're already familiar with her work and want to hear her in a different context—working through material connected to musical theater—this one delivers exactly that. It's the kind of album that works because it knows what it is.